Bakery Bethlehem specializes in Colombian baked goods that multiple reviewers say are hard to find elsewhere in Bucks County. The fresh bread earns particularly enthusiastic reviews—one customer called it the best they'd ever tasted, noting it arrived warm from the oven. The guava pastry stands out as a signature item, with one reviewer so impressed they immediately purchased five more. Traditional Colombian items include almojabana, a cheese bread that regulars order alongside hot chocolate and elephant ears. The empanadas come in multiple varieties, with both chicken and pepperoni versions earning specific praise. One guest noted the pepperoni roll as the softest and best-tasting they'd encountered. This selection of Latin American specialties fills a niche in the Levittown area, where few bakeries offer these traditional items. The bakery opens at 7:00 AM daily, allowing customers to pick up fresh bread and pastries for breakfast.
At least five reviewers praised this item, with one customer so impressed they immediately purchased five more, calling it "OMG!!! so good"
Multiple reviewers called it the best they'd ever tasted, noting it arrives fresh and warm from the oven
Appear in at least four positive reviews, with the pepperoni roll specifically called "the softest and best tasting" one reviewer had encountered
Based on review patterns, the guava pastry, fresh bread, and empanadas represent the core items to try. At least five reviewers specifically mentioned the guava pastry, with one declaring it deserving of an immediate repeat order. The bread receives similar acclaim across multiple reviews for its fresh, warm quality. For savory options, empanadas appear in at least four reviews, with chicken and pepperoni varieties both recommended. The cheesecake earned detailed praise from one reviewer who called it "PRIMO" with perfect consistency and crust; another ordered the strawberry cheesecake and rated it delicious. The tiramisu and flan also appear in reviews, though one guest found the flan rubbery. Regulars recommend the almojabana paired with hot chocolate and elephant ears. The cake pops receive a 10/10 rating from one enthusiastic customer. Prices remain budget-friendly, with most items under $15 per person according to the restaurant's price level.
At least seven reviewers specifically mentioned ordering custom cakes from Bakery Bethlehem for events including birthdays, baby showers, retirement parties, and Thanksgiving. Photos show elaborate themed designs including a Fortnite cake with smooth blue frosting, green buttercream grass, and character images, plus a Harry Potter-themed order and a disco birthday cake decorated with rainbow icing drips, vinyl records, and dancer toppers. Reviewers consistently praise both the visual presentation and taste, with one retirement party host noting guests "could not stop raving about how delicious it was." The cake texture earns specific mentions—one customer described it as moist with light, not-too-sweet icing. The bakery accommodates last-minute requests, with one reviewer grateful the owner helped fulfill a rushed order. Pricing is described as reasonable. The combination of custom design work and flavor quality makes the bakery a go-to for celebration cakes in the Levittown area.
Bakery Bethlehem functions as both a community bakery for the area's Colombian population and a destination for customers seeking alternatives to standard American bakery offerings. One Colombian customer wrote "I've been looking for a local Colombian spot. I love this place," becoming a frequent visitor. The family-owned operation maintains consistent hours seven days a week (7:00 AM to 7:00 PM Monday through Saturday, 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM Sunday), making it accessible for morning pastry runs, midday coffee breaks, or afternoon dessert pickups. The venue works well for solo visits, quick bites, family outings, and breakfast stops. Staff receive consistent praise across reviews for friendly, pleasant service. One reviewer noted the food appeals to those who enjoy Latin American flavors, acknowledging it fills a specific niche with little local competition. Budget-conscious customers appreciate the under-$15 price point, while the custom cake service attracts party planners throughout Bucks County.
Located at
Levittown Town Center| Loading... | — |
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem offers free lot parking and free street parking.
Bakery Bethlehem does not accept reservations. Walk-ins are welcome.
Bakery Bethlehem is open: Monday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Thursday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Friday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Saturday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Sunday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem is a great choice for large groups and parties.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem is family-friendly.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem offers takeout and delivery.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem has wheelchair accessible entrance and accessible parking.
Bakery Bethlehem accepts major credit cards and contactless payments.
Bakery Bethlehem is known for its Colombian pastries, fresh-baked bread, and custom celebration cakes. The guava pastry receives particularly enthusiastic reviews, with one customer so impressed they immediately bought five more. The fresh bread earns consistent praise across reviews, with guests describing it as warm from the oven and the best they've tasted. Custom cakes represent a significant part of the business, with reviewers highlighting elaborate themed designs for birthdays, baby showers, and other celebrations. Traditional Colombian items like almojabana and empanadas fill a niche rarely found elsewhere in the area.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem creates custom celebration cakes that receive consistent praise in reviews. At least seven reviewers mentioned ordering cakes for birthdays, baby showers, retirement parties, and Thanksgiving. Photos show elaborate themed designs including Fortnite, Harry Potter, and disco themes with detailed decorations. Customers praise both the visual presentation and taste, with one noting the cake was moist with light, not-too-sweet icing. The bakery accommodates last-minute requests, with one reviewer grateful the owner helped fulfill a rushed order. Pricing is described as reasonable.
The guava pastry, fresh bread, and empanadas represent the signature items based on review patterns. At least five reviewers specifically mentioned the guava pastry, with one calling it so good they ordered five more immediately. The fresh bread receives acclaim across multiple reviews for being warm and flavorful. Empanadas appear in at least four reviews, with both chicken and pepperoni varieties recommended. The cheesecake earns detailed praise for its consistency and crust. Traditional Colombian items like almojabana (cheese bread) are ordered regularly by customers seeking authentic Latin American baked goods.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem serves as a solid breakfast option in Levittown, opening at 7:00 AM daily. The bakery offers fresh bread, pastries, empanadas, and hot chocolate that work well for morning meals. Multiple reviewers mention visiting in the morning for baked goods, with one noting their first-morning visit prompted them to "run, don't walk" to try the offerings. The budget-friendly pricing (under $15 per person) and quick-bite format make it practical for breakfast stops. Colombian specialties like almojabana and elephant ears provide alternatives to standard American breakfast pastries.
Bakery Bethlehem offers multiple empanada varieties including chicken and pepperoni. The pepperoni roll receives specific praise from one reviewer who called it the softest and best-tasting they'd encountered. Chicken empanadas appear in several positive reviews, with one customer ordering them alongside tiramisu and strawberry cheesecake. However, one reviewer expressed disappointment with a chicken empanada that contained mostly potato with little chicken. At least four reviews mention empanadas as highlights of their orders, suggesting they represent a popular item on the menu.
Yes, Bakery Bethlehem specializes in Colombian baked goods and serves as a destination for the area's Colombian community. Traditional items include guava pastries, almojabana (cheese bread), and empanadas. One Colombian customer wrote they had been searching for a local Colombian spot and became a frequent visitor after discovering this bakery. Another reviewer noted that customers need to appreciate Latin American flavors, acknowledging the bakery fills a specific niche with little competition in the area. The family-owned business combines Colombian specialties with custom cake services and familiar bakery items.
Have more questions about Bakery Bethlehem? Feel free to contact them directly.
No community photos yet
Be the first to share your experience!
Been here?
Share your experience with others
💡 These are general recommendations. Actual conditions may vary. Check Bakery Bethlehem's hours and call ahead during peak times.
| Loading... | — |
Claim your free listing to update information, add photos, and respond to reviews.
New restaurant openings, seasonal events, and updates to the directory — one email a month.
© 2026 Best of Bucks County. All rights reserved.
