What to Order at Maggio's Restaurant, Bar & Ballroom
Based on review analysis, the chicken parm stands out as a signature dish, with one reviewer declaring it "awesome." The stromboli earns enthusiastic praise from a long-time customer who describes it with "absolutely love." For seafood, the mussels appear on the menu served in a broth and topped with what photo analysis identifies as parmesan cheese. The cheesesteak sandwich, photographed with generous melted cheese filling and served with french fries, coleslaw, and a pickle, represents the American side of the menu. Photo evidence also shows a chicken and mushroom pasta dish with sauce, featuring what appears to be a generous serving of mushrooms and chicken. The chocolate strawberry milkshake receives specific recommendation from one reviewer who calls it "DELICIOUS, a must have." Weekend breakfast service offers a buy-one-get-one-for-$1 promotion, though one reviewer noted the bottomless mimosas at $21. The menu spans American bar food, Italian classics, and pizza, though multiple reviewers note the menu has been reduced following recent renovations.
The Maggio's Restaurant, Bar & Ballroom Experience
The atmosphere at Maggio's has undergone significant transformation following recent renovations. Photo analysis reveals a dimly lit interior with numerous televisions throughout, creating what one reviewer describes as a "very noisy" sports bar environment. The dining area is now consolidated exclusively within the bar space, which multiple reviewers characterize as "dark, crowded" and "super cramped." One guest noted being "seated at a table which was right up against" adjacent seating. Three reviewers specifically mentioned the space feeling cramped following the layout changes. Service experiences vary, with one guest noting their waiter was "a Lil swamped on his tables, and didn't get a chance to stop and check on us," while another reported appetizers arriving after 44 minutes. The ballroom side presents an entirely different atmosphere—photo evidence shows elegant event spaces with round tables, white linens, grey runners, green napkins, and floral centerpieces suitable for formal occasions. For a first visit, expect a casual sports bar atmosphere with multiple screens if dining in the restaurant area, or request information about the ballroom spaces for private events.
Planning Your Visit to Maggio's Restaurant, Bar & Ballroom
Maggio's operates seven days a week with 11 AM openings Monday through Friday and 8 AM starts on Saturday and Sunday for breakfast service, staying open until midnight daily. The restaurant is located at 400 2nd Street Pike in Hampton Square, Southampton, and can be reached at 215-322-7272 for dining or 215-364-4983 for catering inquiries. Online ordering is available through Toast for takeout. The venue operates at a moderate price level of $15-30 per person according to Google data. Based on review patterns, Maggio's works best for groups and events—five reviewers specifically praised its capability for accommodating parties and catering functions. The weekend breakfast service includes promotional pricing with buy-one-get-one-for-$1 deals. The venue offers private dining options in its ballroom spaces. However, prospective diners should note that recent renovations have eliminated the traditional dining room, consolidating all restaurant seating into the bar area—a change that seven of 20 reviewers mentioned, with several long-time customers expressing disappointment about the loss of the family-style dining atmosphere.