Cramer Bakery draws regular customers specifically for its Eastern European-style pastries that maintain old-world baking traditions. Multiple reviewers return consistently for hamantaschen with poppy filling earning particular praise as the best variety, alongside European-style rugelach that differs from more common American interpretations. The bakery produces babka in multiple varieties including chocolate, cinnamon, and almond options. Suganiyot, the traditional jelly-filled donuts also called jelly-granulate variety by customers, appear regularly in the display cases. One reviewer specifically praised the poppyseed roll as the best available in the area. Beyond specialty items, the bakery maintains a reputation for quality cookies, with one customer simply declaring them "the best cookies around." Fresh bread loaves remain available daily, connecting to what one reviewer called the "small town bakery tradition" that owner Tom continues.
Multiple reviewers return regularly for this Eastern European specialty, specifically calling the poppy variety the best available
Traditional Eastern European baked good available in multiple varieties that regular customers specifically mention among their repeat purchases
One reviewer specifically called this the best poppyseed roll in the area, distinguishing it from competitors
Custom cake design represents a core specialty at this Yardley bakery, with the establishment inviting customers to bring any design concept for execution. According to the restaurant's website, the bakery will create any idea customers find or imagine. Photo evidence demonstrates this range, from two-tiered wedding cakes adorned with fresh orange and yellow roses and custom 'Mr. & Mrs.' toppers to children's birthday cakes featuring buttercream flowers and decorative piping. One parent reported their son's first birthday cake looked incredible and tasted delicious at a very reasonable price after the bakery incorporated customer-provided animal toppers into an original design. Baseball-themed cookies show the bakery's capability for personalized items, with individual cookies decorated with baseball stitching and different children's names, then individually wrapped with ribbon. The bakery also produces elaborate dessert trays for parties—one Christmas Eve tray allowed all guests to take at least two desserts while still leaving extras, with every item described as baked to perfection, fresh, and flavorful.
Customer experiences at Cramer Bakery show a sharp divide, with 14 of 20 reviewers awarding five stars while 6 gave one or two stars, creating a polarized response pattern. Positive reviews consistently mention helpful staff who assist with carrying items to cars and provide friendly service. One guest who visited after seeing the bakery on television specifically called out how nice and helpful the staff proved during their visit. However, negative experiences reveal concerning patterns around customer service and order accuracy. Multiple reviewers reported being ignored by counter staff who were talking among themselves, with one customer walking around for three minutes without acknowledgment before two men entered and received immediate attention. Order accuracy issues appeared in multiple reviews, including a gender reveal cake with incorrect details despite clear instructions and a birthday cake with the child's name spelled wrong despite providing it via email and in-person conversation. One customer described an aggressive parking lot confrontation with the owner regarding parking space usage in a shared lot.
The bakery occupies a well-maintained building with traditional architectural styling in a retail area shared with other businesses including a CVS pharmacy. Inside, rustic wooden display cases present the daily selection, creating what one visitor described as "one of the cutest bakeries" they'd experienced in years with a "top tier" atmosphere. Seasonal displays show attention to presentation, with individually wrapped gingerbread men cookies bearing branded "Cramer's Bakery Seasons Greetings" labels arranged in wooden cases alongside promotional signage advertising deals like "Buy 3, Get 4th Free." Display cases showcase finished cakes topped with chocolate-covered strawberries and whipped cream, red velvet cupcakes with decorative frosting flowers, and various pastries. The visual appeal led one customer to joke the bakery could "easily bankrupt" regular visitors. The bakery functions as a grab-and-go establishment rather than a sit-down cafe, with customers selecting items from displays and placing custom orders for future pickup.
Cramer Bakery operates seven days weekly with extended hours most days—Tuesday through Saturday from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Sunday from 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and Monday from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM. The bakery accepts both walk-in customers for immediate purchases and advance orders for custom cakes and dessert trays. According to the restaurant's website, customers needing items the same day should call (215) 493-2760 or stop by the location at 16 E Afton Ave in Yardley. The establishment posts holiday hours and order deadlines on its website, important for customers planning celebration cake orders. Pricing falls in the moderate range at approximately $15-30 per person for typical purchases, though individual pastry prices vary—one couple paid what they considered a premium for high hats, while another customer reported $25 for two lobster tails felt excessive for the quality received. Multiple reviewers noted their positive experiences with the pickup process for pre-ordered items. Parking is available in a shared lot serving multiple businesses, though one review mentioned a confrontation regarding parking space designation.
Loading reviews...
| Loading... | — |
Yes, Cramer Bakery Inc offers free lot parking.
Cramer Bakery Inc does not accept reservations. Walk-ins are welcome.
Cramer Bakery Inc is open: Monday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM; Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Thursday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Friday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Saturday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM; Sunday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM.
Yes, Cramer Bakery Inc is a great choice for large groups and parties.
Yes, Cramer Bakery Inc is family-friendly.
Yes, Cramer Bakery Inc offers takeout.
Yes, Cramer Bakery Inc has wheelchair accessible entrance and accessible parking.
Cramer Bakery Inc accepts major credit cards and contactless payments.
Cramer Bakery Inc is known for Eastern European-style pastries and custom celebration cakes. Multiple regular customers specifically return for hamantaschen with poppy filling, European-style rugelach, and babka available in chocolate, cinnamon, and almond varieties. The bakery also produces suganiyot (jelly-filled donuts), crumb cake, and what one reviewer called the best poppyseed roll in the area. Custom cakes represent a core specialty, with the bakery executing customer design concepts for birthdays, weddings, and special occasions. The establishment maintains traditional small-town bakery practices while offering modern online ordering convenience.
Based on consistent review mentions, order the hamantaschen with poppy filling which multiple customers called the best variety, the European-style rugelach, or babka in chocolate, cinnamon, or almond flavors. The poppyseed roll earned specific recognition as the best in the area from one reviewer. For something different, try the high hats which first-time customers found very tasty, or the suganiyot (jelly-granulate donuts). Cookies receive consistent praise with one customer simply calling them the best around. For celebrations, the custom cakes earn positive feedback for both appearance and taste at reasonable prices. If attending a party, the mini dessert trays provide variety with everything baked fresh.
Yes, custom cakes represent a specialty at Cramer Bakery Inc. According to the restaurant's website, customers can bring any design idea they have or find, and the bakery will create it. One parent reported ordering a first birthday cake by sending pictures of their vision and asking the bakery to incorporate animal toppers they'd purchased—the final cake looked incredible and tasted delicious at a very reasonable price. Photo evidence shows the bakery executes elaborate designs from two-tiered wedding cakes with fresh roses to baseball-themed cookies with individual names. However, some reviewers reported order accuracy issues, so confirming details carefully when placing orders is advisable.
Cramer Bakery Inc in Yardley specializes in Eastern European-style pastries that draw regular customers specifically for traditional items. The bakery produces hamantaschen (particularly praised in poppy filling), European-style rugelach that differs from more common American versions, and babka in multiple varieties including chocolate, cinnamon, and almond. They also make suganiyot, the traditional jelly-filled donuts. One reviewer specifically noted they return regularly for these items and praised the European-style preparation. The poppyseed roll earned recognition as the best in the area, connecting to old-world baking traditions that one customer said owner Tom keeps alive.
Based on review evidence, customers have successfully ordered custom cakes with lead times ranging from about two and a half weeks to shorter windows, though the bakery's website posts specific holiday order deadlines suggesting advance planning is important during busy seasons. One customer went into the store on January 28th for a cake needed on February 15th, providing about 18 days notice. For same-day needs of regular bakery items, the website instructs customers to call (215) 493-2760 or stop by the location. Given that some reviewers reported order accuracy issues, placing orders with adequate lead time allows for detail confirmation and reduces the chance of errors on important celebration cakes.
While Cramer Bakery Inc opens as early as 7:00 AM most days (9:00 AM on Mondays), making it suitable for breakfast visits, the specific items reviewers mention as regular purchases include crumb cake, various donuts (suganiyot in jelly-granulate variety), and babka in chocolate, cinnamon, and almond varieties. The bakery produces fresh bread loaves daily, connecting to traditional bakery breakfast options. High hats and cookies also appear in the regular selection. According to the restaurant's website, the bakery offers handmade baked goods that would suit morning purchases, though reviews focus more on specialty pastries and custom cake orders than specifically breakfast-oriented items like breakfast sandwiches or egg dishes.
Have more questions about Cramer Bakery Inc? Feel free to contact them directly.
No community photos yet
Be the first to share your experience!
Been here?
Share your experience with others
💡 These are general recommendations. Actual conditions may vary. Check Cramer Bakery Inc's hours and call ahead during peak times.
| Loading... | — |
Claim your free listing to update information, add photos, and respond to reviews.
New restaurant openings, seasonal events, and updates to the directory — one email a month.
© 2026 Best of Bucks County. All rights reserved.
